My Fully Human Written College Application Essay Says 95% AI Generated

Understanding AI Detection in College Essays: A Student’s Perspective on Authenticity and Integrity

In today’s digital age, students often turn to AI tools like ChatGPT to enhance their writing, seeking feedback and suggestions to refine their essays. However, this practice has raised important questions about authenticity, detection, and ethical writing. Recently, a student shared their experience with a college application essay that was flagged as AI-generated, despite their efforts to ensure it remained personal and original.

The Student’s Journey with AI-Assisted Editing

The student wrote a heartfelt college essay, focusing on sharing their unique story. To improve the clarity and flow, they sought assistance from ChatGPT, asking for constructive feedback. It’s important to note that they did not copy text from the AI; instead, they used it as a collaborative partner, mainly receiving suggestions such as removing unnecessary details and being more specific about certain points. Their goal was to polish their essay while maintaining its authenticity.

The Unexpected Outcome: AI-Generated Flagging

Despite these precautions, the student’s English teacher reviewed the essay and noticed that it was flagged by AI detection software. This led to concern and confusion: the student’s intent was simply to refine their own work, not to pass it off as AI-produced. Some peers and online discussions suggested that the system’s inability to detect the essay as human-generated might be the reason for the flag—particularly since the student’s process involved AI assistance rather than outright copying.

The Dilemma: Rephrasing or Respecting Authenticity?

The common advice in such situations is to rephrase the essay entirely, aiming to bypass AI detection algorithms. However, the student expressed a clear reluctance to do so, as they poured genuine effort and personal storytelling into their original work. Their concern is valid: changing the essay might diminish its authenticity and the personal voice that makes it compelling.

Exploring Potential Solutions and Best Practices

This situation highlights a broader challenge many students face: navigating AI tools ethically while respecting the integrity of their own work. Here are some considerations and potential strategies:

1. Stay Authentic: Use AI as a brainstorming or editing tool, but ensure the final essay reflects your voice and experiences. Avoid overly relying on AI-generated content.

2. Document Your Process: Keep records of how you developed your essay, including initial drafts, feedback, and revisions. This can demonstrate your genuine effort if questions arise.

3. Focus on Personal Style: Write in your natural voice