Gemini keeps merging/confusing similar scenes in long narratives. Any workarounds?

Enhancing Long-Form Narrative Consistency with AI: Strategies to Address Scene Confusion in ChatGPT-Style Models

In recent years, AI-driven tools such as ChatGPT and other language models have become invaluable for writers and storytellers seeking to craft long-form narratives, facilitate collaborative storytelling, or serve as virtual Dungeon Masters for solo tabletop RPG adventures. However, despite their impressive capabilities, these models sometimes encounter challenges in maintaining contextual clarity across extended conversations. One prevalent issue is the tendency for the AI to confuse or merge distinct scenes, actions, or character states, especially when similar or repeated elements are involved.

Understanding the Challenge

As users engage in lengthy dialogue with AI models, the context accumulates, but the model’s ability to accurately track multiple scenes or sequential events can diminish. For example, an AI might:

• Misattribute actions from one scene to another, leading to continuity errors.
• Reiterate earlier dialogue or decisions, creating loops or contradictions.
• Confuse different locations or character states after multiple transitions.

These problems often manifest more acutely when scenes involve similar actions or elements, such as descending multiple ladders or revisiting places, which can cause the AI to “merge” or “mix up” these events.

Practical Scenarios

Let’s explore a couple of typical situations where such confusion can occur:

1. Navigating Multiple Levels in a RPG Setting

A user might describe their character descending from Deck A to Deck B, exploring Deck B, then attempting to go further down to Deck C. However, the AI might erroneously describe the descent back to Deck B or repeat previous locations, causing a disjointed or inconsistent narrative. Correcting this might lead to the AI conflating past and present actions, trapping the conversation in a loop.

1. Managing Complex Character Interactions

In storytelling, characters might travel between points of interest, engaging in arguments or dialogues. When the storyline involves returning to a previous location or revisiting emotional states, the AI might incorrectly carry over earlier interactions, suggesting characters are still affected by past events when the narrative has advanced.

Strategies to Mitigate Scene Confusion

While no method guarantees perfect fidelity, several techniques can enhance the AI’s ability to maintain scene integrity over long narratives:

1. Explicit Scene Markers

Clearly label each scene or location within the conversation. For example, prepend sections with tags like “[Scene: Deck A]” or “[Location: Point B]” to reinforce boundaries and assist the AI in distinguishing different contexts.

2